The Good Ideas Club · Good ideas
Stop "Use up pensions by an age" setting from pulling spiky lump sums in one-off purchase years, and add a multi-tier Tax Ceiling Selector.
Anonymous · 3 upvotes
Even when Custom order: cash, then ISAs, then pensions is selected and ample cash reserves are available, the Use up pensions by an age algorithm currently pulls extra taxable lump sums from DC pensions during recurring one-off purchase years (such as 5-yearly car replacements). This creates avoidable basic or higher rate income tax spikes in purchase years while leaving adjacent years at £0 tax. In higher-income scenarios, these lumpy DC withdrawals can push total taxable income above £100,000, triggering the 60% Personal Allowance taper trap (between £100,000 and £125,140). Funding one-off capital costs strictly from Cash or ISAs first while keeping DC amortisation smooth in real terms, and allowing users to cap DC withdrawals at 0% Personal Allowance, 20% Basic Rate, or £99,999 PA Taper Ceiling (alongside modelling Year-1 P45/P60 pre-retirement pay and the £5,000 0% Starting Rate for Savings)